Need some guidance about this accident

Man, pens are cheap, I wouldn't buy her one for that accident. I would rather only do it if I wanted to flirt with her, I'd say something like "here, I bought you a new one so you can write me your number" hahahaha But come on, I'm sure she doesn't care about it, pens are cheap.

 

Whether or not you want to buy her a pen is up to you, but I can say, as a woman, I would 100% consider that as flirting. So if you aren't trying to flirt with her, dont bother. I doubt it was her only pen.

 

Ask yourself this... if it was an ugly woman or a man would you feel the same amount of guilt and buy him/her a new pen?

If the answer is yes, buy her a new one but she would probably assume you’re flirting.

If you wouldn’t buy the man or ugly woman a new pen, then you’re only feeling guilty because you are attracted to her and want to make a good impression.

 

"I just wanna be a gentleman and even this accident happened with a boy or a grown man, I would still do this."

Nothing personal mate but this is not being a gentleman. This is taking "nice" to a creepy level. High chance she will not understand the gesture (either think you want to hit on her) or be uncomfortable.

On the other hand, the next time you meet her, just greet her and ask her how the test went. That's a great way to get a conversation going if you are at all interested in being her friend or a possible love interest.

If you just want to buy her a pen for nice-being's sake, I would advise you to refrain. That's certainly really socially awkward. I don't know why you would feel guilty over such a thing, honsetly.

 

If your intention is not to flirt then don't do this. Even if she was a grown man it would still feel like flirting for some gay action. And if she would be a young boy then it's straight up creepy. There is no way that anybody would interpret this any other way than flirting.

Besides, why would you feel guiltily for her being extra clumsy? Come on...