1. Welcome to NoFap! We have disabled new forum accounts from being registered for the time being. In the meantime, you can join our weekly accountability groups.
    Dismiss Notice

Tedx Talk: Everyday Sexism by Laura Bates

Discussion in 'Off-topic Discussion' started by NoBrainer, Dec 4, 2014.

  1. NoBrainer

    NoBrainer Distinguished Fapstronaut

    2,176
    1,740
    143
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LhjsRjC6B8U

    I just found this on youtube. I'd never heard of the "Everyday Sexism" project, but maybe that's because I've been living under a shell for the past year and a half (I don't use twitter/ tumblr etc).

    Here is a great video of Laura Bates' Ted talk, founder of the Everyday Sexism project. It's interesting as you can clearly see some of the effects of saturation of porn in society, and it's effects on men and women (predominantly).

    What do you guys think of the video?
     
  2. IGY

    IGY Guest

    I found this unconvincing and many of the points she made strangely irrelevant. I speak as someone that has never been sexist toward women but, rather, the type of guy that will hold a door open for women etc.
     
  3. NoBrainer

    NoBrainer Distinguished Fapstronaut

    2,176
    1,740
    143
    It resonated with me as lately I've noticed how much I objectified women while I was watching porn. I knew at the time that I needed to treat them as human beings, however there was always this drive, that seemed natural, that always lead me to objectify them. As a result I couldn't make proper conversation with women as I was too busy recalling all the ways I'd fantasised about having sex with them.

    On the bus as well I remember thinking how soft a girl's hair was and that I should reach out and touch it. Thank goodness I was able to reign in the self control not to.

    I now realise my natural sexual drive had been tainted by watching so much porn that I could no longer interact with women as human beings. And due to my nature, that meant I couldn't interact with them at all.

    As someone who is not directly affected by such issues (ie being male), it's sometimes easy to forget these issues even exist. However from talking with friends recently, most of my friends (ie the girls) have witnessed some sort of sexual harassment). For example one girl said she is now reluctant to go running because of all the cat calls and rude remarks she gets from random strangers driving past.

    Specifically, what points did you find irrelevant IGY?
     
  4. IGY

    IGY Guest

    Well, one example: she put up some examples of trolling and mentioned some of the type of things they would say. Well, trolls infect virtually every comment section open to them. If the person they are targeting is a guy they will make male sexist references. Sometimes trolls are ageist, or discriminate on the basis of religion, disability or mental health issues (and more). Because there was no comparison made of these other discriminatory posts, reading out two or three examples that happen to be disgracefully sexist to women has no point of reference whatsoever. That is the kind of thing I mean.
     
  5. beauty

    beauty Fapstronaut

    678
    69
    28
    Well, I'm not entirely sure how to express my views on this without creating a vast debate and a potentially frenzied thread... BUT, I find this revolting.

    I'm all for gender equality. One shouldn't be considered less because of gender, nor should opportunities and progress be defined by your sex. However this is sickening because it's a double standard. Laura goes on to describe how a couple of gents said "look at the tits on that". Now I'm thinking to myself: what if a group of girls were staring at a guy while he walked by, and one of them pronounced "look at the muscles on that". Would a guy care? Why not? Would a guy go as far as to make a deal out of it? I'd beg to differ and say no.

    You know she then goes on to say how various professions are dominated by men. Well yes, there's no denying that. BUT: the exact same can be said for women. Engineering is a male dominated profession. It has been for years. More men like it. Would it not be equal to say that (at least where I'm from) nursing is a female dominated profession? Does anyone say anything about that? I don't think so.

    Anyhow, groping is completely unjustifiable on many levels, but for me, this entire sexist/feminist movement is nauseating because it's a complete and utter double standard.
     
    Last edited: Dec 4, 2014
  6. NoBrainer

    NoBrainer Distinguished Fapstronaut

    2,176
    1,740
    143
    @ IGY: I agree, although picking her out on her perhaps unnecessary response to trolls seems to detract from the greater message given by the video. However it's likely that not all of the responses she received towards her web page were from trolls. There is a growing issue that men and some women see feminism as a threat, an axis of evil as some call it. Feminists have been labelled as "feminazis" by some, not just by trolls. We claim to be a society where men and women are treated equally, yet we dismiss/ criticise anyone who speaks out about underlying issues, such as on the basis of- "oh, get over it and stop making such a fuss".

    Generally people will initially be non-accepting of issues which challenge their version of reality. Take trying to convince a porn addict that the content he/she loves viewing is somehow wrong or unnatural. I believe issues such as objectification and sexual harassment in society are often overlooked as it's simpler to ignore the issue and pretend it doesn't exist.
     
    Last edited: Dec 4, 2014
  7. NoBrainer

    NoBrainer Distinguished Fapstronaut

    2,176
    1,740
    143
    It's ok man, it's interesting to me to hear people's differing viewpoints. :)

    I think it is difficult to reach perfect solutions on issues such as this, as the implications of such issues are complex and far reaching. With the example of the social justice system, I'm much more in favour of an equitable system, rather than an equal system. I agree, bias or favouritism should be avoided when conducting formal matters of justice, however treating such matters as a double standard is ignoring that issues regarding treatment of men and women are fundamentally different.

    I would be surprised and not entirely happy if some women said about me "look at the muscles on that". Although such a remark could be received as a complement, the use of the article "that" rather than using a personal pronoun gives the impression that the women would be viewing the man as an object rather than a human being. Therefore this is still objectification. Perhaps a better example, (since muscle definition is viewed as naturally desirable and to be obtained by both genders) is "look at the arse on that". You can't change the size or shape of your bottom. Some men can be quite self conscious about the size of their bottom. Therefore remarking about their bottom as if the person were an extension of their arse can seem most offensive!

    If a feminist movement (as you call it) is unacceptable to you, how do you suggest mitigating issues such as sexual harassment (or at least influencing people's viewpoints to encourage a social change- given you say groping is unjustifiable)?
     
  8. beauty

    beauty Fapstronaut

    678
    69
    28
    Well, men and women are inherently different. And that's something people, more so feminists, need to keep in mind. Women will never be the same as men. And vice versa. We are different creatures, operating under different hormones and social classifications. It's just irritating when a woman gets angry when men objectify her breasts (which is naturally desirable) and instead of of taking it as a compliment, they turn it into a whole schpeal about how women are inferior to men. If a woman said "look at the arse on that one", would a man get all wound up and begin a rant about how men are treated differently? Hell no. And that's where the whole double- standard comes in that really bothers me. It really does.

    How to mitigate unacceptable behaviour such as sexual harassment? I'm not entirely sure. However to immediately pinpoint men as the perpetrators is vexing. Men are raped, abused and sexually harassed by women as well. Yet absolutely nobody talks and brings those issues forth. And that's the problem with this double-standard.

    Where I'm from, women are not in any means treated inferior to men. Heck there are more women at my university than there are men. Yet feminists everywhere push for so-called equality. I guess in certain parts of the world this is an issue. Where I live it sure as hell isn't. Where will it end?
     
    Last edited: Dec 4, 2014
  9. IGY

    IGY Guest

    I agree beauty. Feminism isn't about equality. It is about superiority.

    Almost all of the work categories she listed in her opening gambit are simply a matter of preference. For example, there are far more top quality chefs that are men. You could probably find some figures saying that the ratio is similar to other professions she picked out. But why? The reason that relates most directly to these things is that most women do not want to work as politicians, chefs etc because of the long hours involved. That is pragmatism, not sexism.

    Let me give you a slice of real life: I was sexually assaulted by a fellow patient in a mental health unit. I informed the staff and they took no action at all (apart from giving me 2 tranquilizers and telling me to go to my room and to try and relax). They wouldn't even allow me to use the phone on the ward to report the offence. Naturally, I was intimidated by his presence and asked that he be moved to another ward. They said no, but said I could go to another ward if I wanted! The next day he sexually assaulted a female patient. He was removed from the ward in a matter of minutes!

    You see if you are a bloke you are told: "oh, get over it and stop making such a fuss".
     
  10. NoBrainer

    NoBrainer Distinguished Fapstronaut

    2,176
    1,740
    143
    I agree, men and women are inherently different. However there is a difference between natural desire and objectification. I disagree that a man wouldn't feel upset if he was objectified. No one wants to be or should be objectified by another. The problem with "what if a guy was objectified by a woman" is that men aren't objectified by women. This hypothetical situation is not representative of real life, as men are not directly affected by the differing treatment of men and women.

    I agree, as are men raped by men and women raped by women. But generally I believe that sexual harassment is not taken seriously enough in any case.

    Anyone's views on feminism boil down to what they define as feminism. However I do not think feminism can be defined only to seek social justice in womens' favour. I believe that feminism recognises that there is a difference in the way that men and women are treated and seeks to reach an equitable system to benefit both men and women (ie prevent harassment/objectification/assault of any man or women by any other man or woman). In that way a true equality can be reached.
     
  11. NoBrainer

    NoBrainer Distinguished Fapstronaut

    2,176
    1,740
    143
    I disagree. Yes, there will be some underlying preferences of different genders in different jobs, such as Engineering being more likely to appeal to your average man than your average woman. However Laura listed a broad range of work categories in her opening- politics, law, arts, science, engineering, media, architecture. In all categories there was some evidence of male dominance in the data. Yes, perhaps less women would want to be chefs, or engineers, but to say women are less dominant in those six categories listed because they wouldn't want to work in them is completely unjustified. Additionally, to say women wouldn't want to work because of the long hours involved is completely unjustified too.


    My deepest sympathies for you IGY. Truly. What happened in that mental hospital sounds horrible and completely unacceptable in the way they handled it. I sympathise as it must have been a very traumatic time for you. :( I believe that in general, sexual assault is not taken seriously enough. In many cases of sexual assault, the victim's rights are down played or ignored completely on the basis that they are "making a fuss". Both men and women are continuously lead to believe that they, the victims are somehow to blame.
     
  12. beauty

    beauty Fapstronaut

    678
    69
    28
    Well there's the problem: men are objectified by women. I have numerous girls whom are friends, and let me be the first to say that some of the comments they make about different blokes are eye-brow raising! I'm not going to go into detail for the sake of time, but this whole objectification thing is a little one-sided to me. Sure porn is usually objectifying a woman. However when women watch porn, what do they look at? The guy's junk. His body. His facial features. Wouldn't that be classified as objectification just as much?

    That's the problem I have with this whole thing. I think feminists are seeking a so-called equality wherein the inequality doesn't even exist. I'm not sure.

    Feminists are pretty good at picking out the sliver in my eye, but they fail to notice the log in their own! ;)
     
    Last edited: Dec 5, 2014
  13. IGY

    IGY Guest

    Not only that beauty, but people speak as if women are the only 'victims' in porn. How about all the men and boys that get exploited in regular porn and in gay porn. Whose heart bleeds for them? Who advocates for their rights or against male sexism. OK, so there are loads of sites advertising [NSFW]big boobs[/NSFW] but there are also loads of sites advertising [NSFW]big cocks[/NSFW]. Also, bear in mind that a lot of so called gay sights are regular used by women and men who are not gay. It is also why teenagers grow up with a complex about the size of their genitals - because the sexual objectification of men.

    My point is not about whether there is more of one type of sexism over another. My point is that there is sexism across the genders. There are also numerous factors why there is a disparity between the ratio of women to men in certain professions. That might include sexism, but it is by no means the only factor. She implied the sole reason for all the ills she presented was only the sexism of women. Consequently, her argument was simply not credibile. I don't wish to engage in a virtually endless back and forth about her video because I think it is intentionally misleading and narrow.
     
  14. IGY

    IGY Guest

    Having just said to beauty that - I don't wish to engage in a virtually endless back and forth about her video because I think it is intentionally misleading and narrow - I fell it is only fair to conclude my contribution to this thread by responding to your last messages to me and because you started this topic...

    Thank you for your sympathy for the sexual assault I experienced on 15 February 2006. I had to borrow someone's phone to contact the police as the staff were trying to get me to forget about it. Two officers came. They didn't question what had happened (it was witnesses after all), but they, too, tried to get me to drop the charges on the pretext that it was in my best interests as I would find it too difficult to face him in court! Do you ever hear the countless stories of men who find themselves as the victims of sexual crimes. No. Why, because it is not as newsworthy as when it happens to a woman. Fact!

    It is not unjustified, sadly. She is British and muddled her statistics a bit but, politicians, to take one example. This has been discussed countless times in the UK media. The fact is that women have called for crèche's for children in the Houses of Parliament (the legislative body), flexible hours so that they can juggle pregnancies, child care and child rearing. However, in the absence of these special dispensations, there are few women who are prepared to prioritise their political career or to pursue it when their children are older, as did our female prime minister for 10 years in the 1980s.

    There can be very few things in life that turn on just one factor. This presentation was completely unbalanced and put none of what was being said in any kind of context. A blizzard of information was blurted out at such a speed for the purpose that people wouldn't have time to thoughtfully consider the points being made and there would be a sort of clumsy bludgeoning by extremely selective statistics.

    However, I will reiterate. I am against all sexism in whatever form it takes. I now bow out gracefully ;)
     
  15. NoBrainer

    NoBrainer Distinguished Fapstronaut

    2,176
    1,740
    143
    Thank you so much for your input guys. I'm now wiser on the topic. While I don't agree with everything you guys say there is definitely truth and deep philosophical understanding in your arguments.

    I can't relate to specific data in the UK, since I'm not from the UK and don't keep up with the news there.

    I'm not sure Laura Bates implied that sexism towards women is the only issue relating to sexism that needs attention. I took her end message to mean that love and support from others is so beneficial in working together to overcome any sort of gender related imbalance.

    In general I believe we as a race (ie the human race)- in first world countries at least should act more responsibly to such serious issues as harassment and assault. I'm not sure what the story is in second and third world countries but my guess is generally, even their legislation isn't up to standard.

    I too am against any sort of sexism. I would call myself a feminist for the sake of not being able to find another word and due to my personal meaning of the word. As I stated before I believe that feminism recognises that there are differences in the way that men and women are treated across a variety of complex issues and seeks to reach an equitable system to benefit both men and women equally.
     
  16. beauty

    beauty Fapstronaut

    678
    69
    28

Share This Page