1. Welcome to NoFap! We have disabled new forum accounts from being registered for the time being. In the meantime, you can join our weekly accountability groups.
    Dismiss Notice

The Bondage/BDSM Thread

Discussion in 'Porn Addiction' started by Marcus Aurelius, Aug 16, 2017.

  1. Marcus Aurelius

    Marcus Aurelius Fapstronaut

    1,121
    1,964
    143
    Does anyone else have this particular fetish? I haven't seen it mentioned much on the forums, so I'm curious. It's hard to tell how common it is because obviously it isn't something most people will be comfortable talking about.

    I'm also wondering what people's opinions on it are? Do you think bondage can be part of a healthy relationship? Christian opinions would be especially welcome.

    I feel like if I get married and we never do anything bondage-related, a part of me will always be hungering for it, and that will lead to temptation to seek that pleasure elsewhere (i.e. PMO).
     
  2. MarinoBigFan1984

    MarinoBigFan1984 Fapstronaut

    1,970
    1,476
    143
  3. Marcus Aurelius

    Marcus Aurelius Fapstronaut

    1,121
    1,964
    143
    That was the subgenre you were into?
     
  4. MarinoBigFan1984

    MarinoBigFan1984 Fapstronaut

    1,970
    1,476
    143
    Both of them. Medical fetish and Women's prison fetish
     
  5. I do not have this fetish, but I can offer my opinion as a Christian and comment on the matter of a healthy relationship.
    In order to get a broad understanding of what part this fetish has played in your life I read your very first post last week.
    This excerpt^ reveals that you already know that your fetish is not congruent with Christ-like principles. I agree with you.
    But why? What is the big deal? It's just sex isn't it. Even if it was you inflicting pain on another person, is that acceptable? You know it isn't. Notice how you describe the effect this type of sexual desire was having on you @Marcus Aurelius...
    How does this fetish, what it stirs within you and the harm to the female contravene Christian principles and direct laws?
    So is sexual sadism Christian? The apostle John's words clearly show this cannot be acceptable in 1 John 4:7, 8 [TLB]:

    "Dear friends, let us practice loving each other, for love comes from God and those who are loving and kind show that they are the children of God, and that they are getting to know him better. But if a person isn’t loving and kind, it shows that he doesn’t know God—for God is love."

    So what would be the identifying features of a healthy relationship between the sexes? Note Ephesians 5:28, 29 [NIV] says:

    "In this same way, husbands ought to love their wives as their own bodies. He who loves his wife loves himself. After all, no one ever hated their own body, but they feed and care for their body, just as Christ does the church."
     
  6. AtomicTango

    AtomicTango Fapstronaut

    IGY has said in better detail what I was going to say but I also want to ask whether you had this fetish before or after you became addicted to PMO? If it was porn induced then simply abstaining will rewire your brain and make it go away, but if you had it before then just repressing it may not work. How extreme did this BDSM stuff become anyway?
     
  7. Marcus Aurelius

    Marcus Aurelius Fapstronaut

    1,121
    1,964
    143
    It all started when I was really young. I first masturbated when I was four and I soon linked the pleasure sensation of masturbation with seeing characters on TV or movies get tied up. It is probably significant that I was turned on by restraints and gags before I was turned on by women. So when I was young the gender of the person getting tied up didn't matter.

    I eventually did get turned on by women once puberty hit. At that point I liked masturbating to women in bikinis and underwear (and later with nothing on) along with women who were tied and gagged. I eventually discovered that there was an actual sexual practice called "bondage" and it wasn't just me who was turned on by this stuff. Thus entered bondage porn.

    There was an earlier post in this thread that I wanted to address, but it seems to have been deleted. I won't mention the poster by name for anonymity reasons, but I wanted to address the point made in the post anyway because I think it is important.

    In my introductory post on NoFap, I mentioned how bondage porn was unleashing the sadist within me and I started getting turned on by some pretty bad stuff (e.g. whippings that left marks, women tied in painful positions). This was part of the catalyst for me wanting to give up on porn. The poster basically said that I was aware that the things that turned me on when I was deep into my bondage porn addiction were cruel and objectifying and not in line with a loving relationship or the Christian faith, so why am I asking if I can participate in the bondage scene when I already know the answer?

    First off, I agree that the stuff I was watching is bad and shouldn't be practiced by a loving couple. But here's the thing. I was turned onto seeing people (and now specifically women) bound and gagged from a very young age and long before I started watching porn. What either appeared or ramped up significantly with porn was the cruelty.

    So I'm not asking if cruel or painful sexual practices are compatible with a healthy, Christian relationship. I know that they are not. I want to cut that part out of my sex life completely. I also don't want to be part of "BDSM culture" (e.g. going to conventions, wearing bondage gear in public, wearing leather, have dom/sub roles outside of the bedroom). If I'm honest what it really comes down to is gags. Even restraints are something that I would like, but could do without if that is the wisest course to take. For some reason the sight and sound of a gagged woman is incredibly sexy to me and, because this developed so early, it feels primal. At its most basic, this would mean having otherwise vanilla sex, but she would be gagged. I don't need it to turn me on, but I feel like I would always desire it if I didn't get it, and that desire may cause me, or at least tempt me, to seek that pleasure somewhere else (e.g. PMO).
     
  8. MarinoBigFan1984

    MarinoBigFan1984 Fapstronaut

    1,970
    1,476
    143
    To me both are power related but honestly both have lost their appeal. I have also been able to act out both in role play with partners. The medical one has lost all of its appeal. The prison one is stronger. I think it simply came from watching women in B prison movies from the 80s (which are tame compared to 60-70s ones. I find those creepy). I enjoyed the strip search, the group shower, the general T and A with the big hair. Very few had actual sex scenes. They were the first videos I masturbatered too and since I liked certain parts I probably fast forwarded and hit rewind 5000 times. These were VHS tapes. I didn't even know they made prison porn till my 30s. Even then I watched the more mild erotic ones vs hard core BDSM. The role play really cut back the fetish because it became boring and I'd rather just explore a women's body more sensually. Now I like to massage my partner I find it more erotic and helps bond you to your partner. I could also cuddle for hours. I just love the sight, touch, and feel of women. Their skin is soft and women really have a scent that is both calming and inroxicating at the same time. Listen a man's heartbeat lying next to his lady in bed. It slows down and you feel safe and loved. If I watch porn now it's all erotica. It's about sensuality not power.
     
  9. MarinoBigFan1984

    MarinoBigFan1984 Fapstronaut

    1,970
    1,476
    143
    I really have no desire to go back to those fetishes. Different person and stage in my Life especially with regards to sexuality issues.
     
  10. MarinoBigFan1984

    MarinoBigFan1984 Fapstronaut

    1,970
    1,476
    143
    The actual pain part to me had no appeal. At most the erotica I would watch now might have light spanking but playful not violent. More in the foreplay context. Anything beyond that creeps me out. That's just violence against women to me. There is no sexuality part.
     
    Deleted Account likes this.
  11. MarinoBigFan1984

    MarinoBigFan1984 Fapstronaut

    1,970
    1,476
    143
    I haven't done or watched either for a good 6-8 months before I started the reboot. I wanted it gone. I hit 40 this year and wanted to make some changes in my life. I did it for me not anybody else. It was more aligning my behavior and values than anything else. The interesting part is the ladies all said I'll do this role play for you but nobody else. Why? They all said they felt safe with me. They set the rules not me in terms of how far into the roles per se. Even then if they said I'm not comfortable ok we stop. At most I frisked them nude not conducted an invasive cavity search.
     
  12. Marcus Aurelius

    Marcus Aurelius Fapstronaut

    1,121
    1,964
    143
    That's really interesting. I've noticed that since giving up PMO, I've been craving vanilla sex with a woman on almost an equal level to my cravings for bondage porn. It's a little unexpected, but also welcome.

    I know what you mean about the power thing. Even if I stripped down to just a gag and nothing else, there still is an element of dominance in gagging someone. I guess that's the part of sex that kind of confused me (as someone who has never done it). I almost get the sense that dominance and submission at some level is inherent in sexual practice, but then some talk as if dominance and submission are evil. I don't think they are necessarily as long as it stays in the bedroom and doesn't get carried away.

    I really wouldn't mind it if my desire for restraints and gags gave way to vanilla sex, cuddling etc. In my present state, the idea of never fulfilling my fetish desire seems suffocating at times, but if the desire itself disappeared, I don't think I would mourn it.

    Because I developed it so young, though, I don't know if it can simply go away. And maybe it doesn't have to. We'll see. I'm only two weeks into my reboot and I intend to not have sex until I'm married, so who knows what my desires and brain chemistry will be like when I actually get around to having sex for the first time (Lord willing).
     
  13. MarinoBigFan1984

    MarinoBigFan1984 Fapstronaut

    1,970
    1,476
    143
    To me this is all fantasy not reality. Big difference.
     
  14. MarinoBigFan1984

    MarinoBigFan1984 Fapstronaut

    1,970
    1,476
    143
    Her feeling safe and secure has always taken precedence over my gratification.
     
  15. Marcus Aurelius

    Marcus Aurelius Fapstronaut

    1,121
    1,964
    143
    I think I will see a therapist. It's going to be awkward as heck though...
     
  16. tobias-heretohelp

    tobias-heretohelp Fapstronaut

    31
    51
    18
    There is nothing wrong with being into bdsm and dominance and submission. Anyone that says these things are evil... doesn't have a clue. Many women like to be dominated. Some women like to be dominant themselves. And when you gag and beat a submissive women, yeah you inflict pain to her, but she wants and likes that. So there is nothing evil there.

    BDSM is all about trust and communication. I heard that a study reveilled that bdsm couples have a way more successful relationship than many vanilla couples because you have to communicate A LOT more which is a good thing.
     
  17. My post #5, was deleted by a moderator by mistake. I asked for it to be reinstated, which it has been. Best wishes: IGY.
     
  18. Marcus Aurelius

    Marcus Aurelius Fapstronaut

    1,121
    1,964
    143
    @Jolie: I have taken your advice and have contacted a counselling service.

    I think the important thing is that I want to ditch my sadistic fantasies in favour of a loving relationship with a real woman. The actual desire is there; it isn't just a vague feeling of something I ought to do without any real conviction. I think that will get stuff done.

    As far as where to draw the line in the context of a loving relationship... that is something I guess I will have to play by ear. Every person and relationship is different, I don't now how my long-term reboot will affect my sexuality, and I've never had sex and don't know what affect it would have on me, so it probably wouldn't make sense to draw my line in the sand now when I'm single and celibate (aside from the obvious: no porn, no sadism, no cruelty).
     
    Kenzi likes this.
  19. MarinoBigFan1984

    MarinoBigFan1984 Fapstronaut

    1,970
    1,476
    143
    Porn has never been an issue in a relationship. I don't even watch it then unless we watched it as a couple which has been maybe once in my steady relationships. My ED is medication induced but I try to eliminate porn as much as possible because it can make ED worse.
     
  20. I understand what you are saying. But it still comes back to the basic equation: would such a type of marital sex be in harmony with the Holy Scriptures? Any such decisions must come from prayer, bible reading and thoughtful consideration.
     

Share This Page